On this page
You’re preparing an NNN agreement with a Chinese factory, and at some point you have to put a number in it: how much the factory pays if it leaks your information or uses it for its own purposes. You want a figure large enough that the factory takes it seriously. Push it too high, though, and the negotiation can stall over that one clause, and a court may reduce it later anyway.
For an NNN governed by mainland Chinese law, I work the number out in three steps:
- Estimate what a breach could actually cost you.
- Check that estimate against the deal you are doing with this factory.
- Write down clearly when the amount is owed and how it is counted.
Working in that order gives you a figure you can defend at the negotiating table and, if it comes to that, in court.
Start with the loss a breach could cause
Before you pick a number, list what you would lose if the factory disclosed your information or used it without permission. Start with the concrete costs, because they are the easiest to show later:
- Design, development or prototype spending that the breach would waste.
- The cost of redesigning the product, remaking samples or adjusting tooling to deal with the harm.
- Reasonable spending to stop the damage from spreading. Chinese law lets you recover reasonable costs of limiting further loss.PRC Civil Code, Article 591: Limiting LossThe injured party must take appropriate steps to limit loss. Reasonable costs of doing so are borne by the breaching party.Fujian Communications Administration, official republication
For each item, ask whether the breach really causes it. Money you have already spent on the project counts only to the extent the breach wastes it. If the design or the tooling is still usable after a leak, include just the part that is affected, and make sure the same expense appears only once in your list.
At this stage I would leave out the more uncertain items, such as orders you hoped to win or a general hit to your brand. They are hard to put a figure on before anything has happened, and they tend to inflate the estimate. Proven, foreseeable lost profits can still be recovered under Chinese lawPRC Civil Code, Article 584: Recoverable LossContract damages include benefits that performance would have produced, subject to the loss being caused by the breach and foreseeable at contracting.Fujian Communications Administration, official republication , so if a breach does cost you future business, that claim stays open.
Why is the estimate worth the effort? Because the agreed amount will eventually be measured against the loss. You can agree on damages in advance, and the factory can ask for a reduction if the amount is far above the loss.PRC Civil Code, Article 585: Agreed Damages and ReductionParties may agree a damages amount or calculation method. A court or arbitral tribunal may reduce an excessively high amount on request.Fujian Communications Administration, official republication
The Supreme People’s Court gives a benchmark for “far above”: an amount more than 30% above the loss can generally be considered excessiveSPC Contract General Provisions Interpretation (2023), Article 65An amount exceeding loss by more than 30% may generally be excessive. Courts also weigh the circumstances. Reduction requests by malicious breachers are generally rejected.Supreme People's Court . That is where the common rule of thumb of 130% of the loss comes from. Courts use it as the starting point for their judgment. They also look at the deal as a whole, how far each side performed and who was at fault, and they generally refuse to reduce the amount for a party that breached in bad faith.
One more distinction matters here. When you sign, you are estimating a loss that has not happened yet. In a dispute, the court compares the agreed amount with the loss actually proven in that case. A careful estimate now makes it more likely that the two line up. The general rules on liquidated damages in China cover adjustment in more detail.
Choose an amount that fits the transaction
Once you have an estimate, look at it from the factory’s side. It will want to understand why the amount is what it is, and the clearest answer comes from what it is about to receive: your designs, technical data or customer details, and how much you have invested in them.
The size of the first order is a weaker guide than it seems. A small trial order can still require you to hand over a valuable design, so a modest order can justify a meaningful amount. The reverse also holds: a large order that involves little sensitive information supports a smaller figure. Be specific about what you will disclose and what misuse of it would cost you, and the amount becomes much easier to explain.
As a practical starting point, I usually propose between RMB 100,000 and RMB 500,000, depending on the transaction. It gives both sides a concrete figure to discuss while you work through the likely loss and the scope of protection. This is a working range from my own practice. Some projects justify going above or below it, and whatever the factory agrees to, a court will make its own assessment if a dispute arises.
A good test before you send the draft: can you explain the figure in ordinary business terms, covering what is at risk, why this amount fits and which obligations it backs up? If you can, you are ready to negotiate it.
Make clear when and how the amount applies
The same number can work very differently depending on the words around it. Settle three points in the clause:
- What triggers payment? Name the prohibited disclosures, the prohibited uses of your information, and any direct dealings with customers you want protected.
- How is it counted? Say whether the amount applies to each breach or is a total for the whole agreement, and how a series of related acts will be treated.
- What if the loss is greater? Say how any shortfall will be handled, and check that no other clause in the contract quietly turns this figure into a cap on all liability.
The third point deserves a closer look. If the agreed amount falls short of the loss, you can ask for an increase.PRC Civil Code, Article 585: Increasing Insufficient DamagesWhere agreed damages are below the loss caused, a court or arbitral tribunal may increase the amount on a party's request.Fujian Communications Administration, official republication You will need evidence of the larger loss, so word the clause in a way that lets you claim the gap while each loss is counted only once.
Evidence matters from the start, too. Keep design and prototype invoices, payment records, and the emails or messages showing which files you sent and when. Even with an agreed amount, you still have to prove that the factory breached. And if the amount is challenged, both sides have to back up their positionSPC Contract General Provisions Interpretation (2023), Article 64A party seeking reduction must prove excessiveness. A party defending the amount as reasonable must also provide supporting evidence.Supreme People's Court , so the records you keep now are what will support your figure later.
If you’d like help applying this to your project, I can draft or review the NNN agreement, including the amount and the obligations behind it.
References
- Fujian Communications Administration, official republication of the PRC Civil Code (effective January 1, 2021), Articles 465, 584, 585 and 591: https://fjca.miit.gov.cn/zwgk/zcwj/wjfb/art/2020/art_9f0ef44677164c5eb3a5585bf82a07cb.htmlfjca.miit.gov.cn中华人民共和国民法典应当履行法律规定的和当事人约定的义务,法律规定或者当事人约定第三人可以直接请求债务人向其履行债务,法律规定应当承担侵权责任的,法律、行政法规规定或者当事人约定合同应当采用书面形式订立,第三百五十一条 建设用地使用权人应当依照法律规定以及合同约定支付出让金等费用fjca.miit.gov.cn
- Supreme People’s Court, Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the General Provisions of the Contract Book of the PRC Civil Code (effective December 5, 2023), Articles 64 and 65: https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/419382.htmlwww.court.gov.cn权威发布 - 中华人民共和国最高人民法院最高人民法院政务网站,最高人民法院网,最高人民法院,最高人民法院网是人民群众了解和联系最高人民法院的重要窗口,承载着司法公开、法治宣传、服务群众、接受监督等重要使命。是最高人民法院的政务网站,是最高人民法院在互联网上唯一的正式身份。www.court.gov.cn
Frequently Asked Questions
How much liquidated damages will a Chinese court uphold?
Generally up to 130% of the actual loss, such as wasted design and prototype costs, redesign or retooling costs, and reasonable costs of limiting the damage. Indirect losses are left out.
What amount will a Chinese manufacturer agree to?
In practice, usually RMB 100,000 to RMB 500,000, depending on the size of the transaction. Most manufacturers find a figure in that range commercially reasonable.
Can we agree on liquidated damages before placing an order?
Yes. An NNN can be a stand-alone contract covering what you share before any order. Agree on the protected information, permitted uses and the consequences of breach before you send sensitive files, so the protection applies from the first disclosure.
Should I distrust a factory that asks for a lower amount?
Negotiating the number is normal. Ask why it objects and what it proposes, and watch whether it accepts clear limits on disclosure, unauthorized use and dealing directly with your protected customers. Those answers say more about its intentions.
Can we write that the amount cannot be reduced?
You can write it, but a court can still adjust the amount. Article 64 of the Supreme People's Court's 2023 contract interpretation says a party relying only on such a clause will lose that argument.
Can I claim lawyer and notary fees separately?
Possibly, depending on the contract and the legal basis. State in the NNN how these costs are treated and whether the agreed amount already includes them, and keep receipts for reasonable costs you actually pay.