In-depth report2016–2025 A decade of Chinese court judgments
China supply chain disputes: the international buyer’s report
We read every published judgment we could find in which a foreign buyer and a mainland Chinese supplier ended up in court over a sale of goods. There are 134 cases, with buyers from 42 countries, decided over ten years. This is what they show.
At a glance
The 134 cases at a glance
134cases
77%buyer won all or part
$64Min dispute (128 cases state it, median $116K)
49appealed, 12 changed on appeal
- Buyer won
- Partly won
- Buyer lost
- Lost and paid the seller
Product category
Amount in dispute (USD)
$1M and over: 15 of the 128 cases that state an amount, 70% of the total.
Instance
Where the supplier is
Schematic map: one tile per province. Darker means more cases. 1 cases do not state the province.
Highest court that ruled
Where the buyer is from: 42 countries and territories
Show the data
| Product category | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steel and metals | 17 | 10 | 4 | 3 | 82% |
| Apparel and footwear | 14 | 10 | 2 | 2 | 86% |
| Masks and medical PPE | 14 | 8 | 2 | 4 | 71% |
| Chemicals and raw materials | 12 | 6 | 3 | 3 | 75% |
| Home appliances | 8 | 4 | 2 | 2 | 75% |
| Machinery and components | 8 | 5 | 1 | 2 | 75% |
| Protective gloves | 8 | 6 | 0 | 2 | 75% |
| Household goods and stationery | 7 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 71% |
| Lighting and solar | 7 | 5 | 2 | 0 | 100% |
| Building materials and furniture | 7 | 4 | 1 | 2 | 71% |
| Food and agriculture | 6 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 67% |
| Vehicles and auto parts | 6 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 67% |
| Consumer electronics | 6 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 67% |
| Bags and leather goods | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Textiles and fabrics | 4 | 2 | 0 | 2 | – |
| Packaging | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Not stated | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | – |
| Beauty and personal care | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Amount | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $20K | 14 | 10 | 3 | 1 | 93% |
| $20K–50K | 24 | 20 | 2 | 2 | 92% |
| $50K–200K | 38 | 23 | 6 | 9 | 76% |
| $200K–1M | 37 | 17 | 7 | 13 | 65% |
| $1M and over | 15 | 8 | 4 | 3 | 80% |
| Not stated | 6 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 50% |
| Amount | Cases | Total (USD) | Share of total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under $20K | 14 | 183,218 | 0% |
| $20K–50K | 24 | 780,879 | 1% |
| $50K–200K | 38 | 4,070,457 | 6% |
| $200K–1M | 37 | 14,341,085 | 22% |
| $1M and over | 15 | 44,785,070 | 70% |
| All cases stating an amount | 128 | 64,160,709 | 100% |
| Instance | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First instance only | 84 | 51 | 8 | 25 | 70% |
| Appealed, upheld | 37 | 23 | 9 | 5 | 86% |
| Appealed, changed | 12 | 5 | 6 | 1 | 92% |
| Retrial | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Court | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic court | 50 | 31 | 4 | 15 | 70% |
| Intermediate court | 54 | 33 | 11 | 10 | 81% |
| High court | 29 | 16 | 8 | 5 | 83% |
| Buyer region | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Europe | 32 | 17 | 7 | 8 | 75% |
| East Asia | 24 | 9 | 4 | 11 | 54% |
| North America | 21 | 11 | 6 | 4 | 81% |
| Middle East | 13 | 11 | 1 | 1 | 92% |
| South and Southeast Asia | 10 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 70% |
| Latin America and Caribbean | 6 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 100% |
| Russia and Central Asia | 5 | 3 | 2 | 0 | 100% |
| Oceania | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Africa | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | – |
| Not stated | 19 | 15 | 1 | 3 | 84% |
| Buyer country or territory | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| United States | 16 | 9 | 4 | 3 | 81% |
| South Korea | 11 | 2 | 2 | 7 | 36% |
| Hong Kong | 7 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 57% |
| Japan | 6 | 5 | 0 | 1 | 83% |
| UAE | 6 | 4 | 1 | 1 | 83% |
| Canada | 5 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 80% |
| India | 4 | 2 | 1 | 1 | – |
| Russia | 4 | 2 | 2 | 0 | – |
| Spain | 4 | 2 | 0 | 2 | – |
| Belgium | 3 | 1 | 0 | 2 | – |
| Germany | 3 | 1 | 1 | 1 | – |
| Hungary | 3 | 2 | 0 | 1 | – |
| Italy | 3 | 0 | 2 | 1 | – |
| Australia | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Iran | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Jordan | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Netherlands | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Poland | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Singapore | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | – |
| Slovakia | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Thailand | 2 | 0 | 1 | 1 | – |
| Turkey | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| United Kingdom | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Uruguay | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Barbados | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Belize | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Brazil | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Denmark | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| France | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | – |
| Greece | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Ireland | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Malaysia | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Mozambique | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Norway | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Panama | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Philippines | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Romania | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Saudi Arabia | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Serbia | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| South Africa | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | – |
| Sweden | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Uzbekistan | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Province | Cases |
|---|---|
| Zhejiang | 36 |
| Guangdong | 32 |
| Shandong | 23 |
| Jiangsu | 10 |
| Hebei | 7 |
| Jiangxi | 4 |
| Fujian | 4 |
| Beijing | 3 |
| Shanghai | 3 |
| Hubei | 2 |
| Henan | 2 |
| Hong Kong / mainland | 2 |
| Liaoning | 1 |
| Hunan | 1 |
| Tianjin | 1 |
| Shaanxi | 1 |
| Not stated | 1 |
| Heilongjiang | 1 |
Part one · Going to court
What happens when you sue in a Chinese court, and how long does it take?
- cases that ended at first instance
- 84/134
- appeals that left the first judgment standing
- 37/49
- median time from filing to first judgment
- 8months
Most cases end with the first judgment, and most appeals leave it standing. The next three chapters look at who wins, how far cases go and how long they take.
01The big picture
Can a foreign buyer win a lawsuit against a Chinese supplier in a Chinese court?
Most foreign buyers who sue a Chinese supplier in a Chinese court win at least part of what they ask for.
82%Of the 107 foreign buyers who sued a mainland Chinese supplier, 88 won all or part of their claim.
Many foreign buyers expect a Chinese court to side with the local company. These judgments give little support to that fear. Of the 107 buyers who sued a mainland supplier, 70 won outright and 18 won part of their claim. 19 lost, and in most of those the judgment says why: a gap in the buyer’s own evidence or contract.
It is a different story when the supplier sues. Buyers who defended won 10 of 27 cases, and those who had signed an acknowledgement of debt lost 5 of 6. The courts are the same. What differs is that a supplier who sues usually holds a document the buyer has signed.
- Supplier sued the buyer
All 134 cases
134 · 80 won, 23 partly · 77% got something
Show the data
| Who sued | Cases | Buyer won | Partly won | Buyer lost | Lost and paid the seller |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer sued the supplier | 107 | 70 | 18 | 18 | 1 |
| Supplier sued the buyer | 27 | 10 | 5 | 12 | 0 |
| All cases | 134 | 80 | 23 | 30 | 1 |
02First instance and appeal
Do most cases get appealed, and do appeals change the result?
Most cases end with the first judgment, and most appeals leave it standing.
37/49Of the 134 cases, 84 ended at first instance. Of the 49 that were appealed, the appeal court upheld 37 and changed 12, some of them in the buyer’s favour.
Every one of the 134 cases has a first-instance judgment. For 84, that is the only judgment on record; 49 went on to an appeal and 1 to a retrial. A case with only a first-instance judgment may still have been appealed, with the appeal judgment never published.
The appeal court upheld 37 judgments and changed 12. A change is not always bad news for the buyer: some buyers who lost at first instance won on appeal.
Some judgments were changed on appeal in the buyer’s favour, for example , , .
Show the data
| Instance | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First instance only | 84 | 51 | 8 | 25 | 70% |
| Appealed, upheld | 37 | 23 | 9 | 5 | 86% |
| Appealed, changed | 12 | 5 | 6 | 1 | 92% |
| Retrial | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | – |
| Case | Who sued | Final outcome for the buyer |
|---|---|---|
| Case 9 | Supplier | Buyer won |
| Case 10 | Buyer | Partly won |
| Case 11 | Buyer | Partly won |
| Case 19 | Buyer | Buyer won |
| Case 21 | Supplier | Partly won |
| Case 61 | Buyer | Buyer won |
| Case 74 | Buyer | Partly won |
| Case 75 | Supplier | Buyer lost |
| Case 81 | Supplier | Partly won |
| Case 95 | Supplier | Buyer won |
| Case 96 | Buyer | Buyer won |
| Case 126 | Buyer | Partly won |
03Time and money
How long does a lawsuit against a Chinese supplier take?
Getting from filing to a first-instance judgment takes about eight months at the median.
231 daysHalf of the 76 cases with a recorded filing date had a first-instance judgment within 231 days, about 8 months.
Non-delivery cases moved fastest, with a median of 191 days. Quality cases took 371, because they need testing, expert appraisal and more hearings. An appeal adds several months. Small claims get the same treatment. The median claim was about $116K, 35 claims were under $50K, and the court gave the smallest, $5,320, a full hearing under the UN Sales Convention (CISG).
Time to judgment, by type of case
Each dot is a case, stacked in 30-day bins. The tick marks the median. Square dots took longer than 1200 days.
Show the data
| Group | Cases with dates | Median days |
|---|---|---|
| Paid, never shipped | 30 | 191 |
| Late or partial delivery | 6 | 225 |
| Quality, certification or quantity | 22 | 371 |
| Supplier sued the buyer | 15 | 215 |
| Supplier did not appear | 22 | 211 |
| Supplier contested | 39 | 277 |
| All cases | 76 | 231 |
Claim size and time to judgment
Show the data
| Claim size (USD, estimated) | Cases | Median days |
|---|---|---|
| Under $20K | 8 | 214 |
| $20K–50K | 17 | 173 |
| $50K–200K | 20 | 214 |
| $200K–1M | 23 | 295 |
| $1M and over | 8 | 352 |
Part two · Quality disputes
When the goods are defective, what wins?
- buyers who sued over quality and won all or part
- 11/25
- buyers who raised quality in defence and paid less or won
- 6/7
The same quality problem fares much better as a defence than as a claim.
04Quality claims
Can a buyer win a quality dispute against a Chinese supplier?
In a quality dispute, photos and emails alone rarely win the case for the buyer.
5/25When the supplier fought a defective-goods claim, the buyer won outright in only 5 of 25 cases. Another 14 were lost.
Most of the cases foreign buyers lose are quality disputes. The supplier says the goods were fine when they left the factory, and the buyer then has to prove they were not, against a standard the court can apply. Photos taken in a warehouse abroad, complaints from the buyer’s own customers and test reports the supplier never agreed to were rarely enough.
These are the reasons the judgments give in the 19 cases buyers lost.
Show the data
| Reason | Cases |
|---|---|
| Buyer's own conduct | 5 |
| Weak evidence | 5 |
| Other | 3 |
| Sued the wrong party | 2 |
| No quality standard in contract | 2 |
| Contract's inspection terms not followed | 2 |
Where the contract made the difference
When the contract named a standard, a quality claim had something to stand on. One contract said “seamless pipe”; testing found welds, and the buyer won (). Two contracts named no standard, and both buyers lost (, ).
05When you are sued
Do quality problems work better as a claim or as a defence?
The same quality problem gets further as a defence than as a claim.
6/7In 7 cases the supplier sued for the price and the buyer pointed to quality problems. In 6 of them the buyer paid less or won outright.
When buyers sued over defects and the supplier fought back, 11 of 25 won all or part of their claim. When the buyer held back payment, the supplier sued for the price and the buyer then pointed to the defects, 6 of 7 buyers paid less or won outright.
- Buyer won
- Partly won
- Buyer lost
- Lost and paid the seller
Show the data
| Situation | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer sued over quality, supplier contested | 25 | 5 | 6 | 14 | 44% |
| Buyer raised quality against the supplier’s claim | 7 | 2 | 4 | 1 | 86% |
| Buyer sued over certification or compliance | 6 | 5 | 1 | 0 | 100% |
Part three · Which claims win
Which disputes do buyers win most often?
- paid and never shipped: buyer won
- 42/49
- buyer still won when the supplier fought
- 23/30
What you sue over matters more than where you are from or which law applies.
06When you sue
Which disputes with Chinese suppliers do buyers win most often?
Buyers win most often when the supplier took the money and shipped nothing.
42/49Of the 49 cases where the supplier was paid and never shipped, buyers won 42.
A non-delivery case turns on documents: the contract, the bank transfer, the messages in which the supplier promised a shipping date. A court can check every one of them. Even when the supplier showed up and fought, buyers won 23 of 30.
Split the cases by where the buyer is from, by governing law or by whether the supplier appeared, and the type of claim still makes the biggest difference.
Best odds: Certification or compliance failure (4 of 5 won). Worst: Defective goods (5 of 25).
- Buyer won
- Partly won
- Buyer lost
- Lost and paid the seller
Show the data
| Claim | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paid, never shipped | 49 | 42 | 2 | 5 | 90% |
| Late or partial delivery | 15 | 10 | 5 | 0 | 100% |
| Certification or compliance failure | 6 | 5 | 1 | 0 | 100% |
| Short quantity | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Defective goods | 29 | 9 | 6 | 14 | 52% |
| Other | 6 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 100% |
| Claim | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paid, never shipped | 30 | 23 | 2 | 5 | 83% |
| Late or partial delivery | 11 | 7 | 4 | 0 | 100% |
| Certification or compliance failure | 5 | 4 | 1 | 0 | 100% |
| Short quantity | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | – |
| Defective goods | 25 | 5 | 6 | 14 | 44% |
| Other | 6 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 100% |
Where the contract made the difference
Where the contract set a delivery date and damages for late delivery, buyers got the damages on top of the refund. One contract set the damages at 20% of the undelivered part, and the court awarded them in full (). Another set 20%, and the court applied it as written ().
Part four · Getting paid, and the contract
Once you win, can you collect? And what does the contract add?
- supplier never appeared: buyer won
- 27/28
- owner or other individual held liable, when asked
- 11/16
- lawyer fees awarded, when claimed
- 2/8
The law gets you your money back. Anything beyond that depends on the contract.
07After you win
Can a buyer hold the shareholders of a Chinese supplier personally liable?
Most buyers who asked the court to make a shareholder or other individual liable got that ruling.
27/28Buyers won 27 of the 28 cases in which the supplier never appeared.
What the judgments do not record is whether the buyer was ever paid. In one case a buyer won US$1.16 million against a supplier that was already in bankruptcy.
In 16 cases the buyer also sued the people behind the company, and in 11 the court held the owner or another individual liable. Most were sole shareholders of one-person companies who could not show that the company’s money was kept apart from their own.
- Buyer won
- Partly won
- Buyer lost
- Lost and paid the seller
Show the data
| Situation | Cases | Won | Partly won | Lost | Won or partly won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Supplier did not appear | 28 | 27 | 1 | 0 | 100% |
| Supplier contested | 79 | 43 | 17 | 19 | 76% |
| Buyer also sued a shareholder or individual | 16 | 13 | 1 | 2 | 88% |
08The contract
Can a buyer recover lawyer fees, or get a deposit back double, from a Chinese supplier?
Lawyer fees, and a deposit returned double, both depend on the contract saying so.
2/8Lawyer fees were claimed in 8 cases and awarded in 2. Each time, the contract provided for them.
The chart lists every judgment in which a contract term, or a document signed after the dispute began, helped or hurt the buyer.
- Buyer won
- Partly won
- Buyer lost
- Lost and paid the seller
Paper after things go wrong
Get the seller's admissions and refund promises in writing. Do not sign statements of debt yourself without advice.
Lawyer-fee clausefees awarded 2/8
State that the party in breach pays the other side's lawyer fees. Without it, courts rarely award them.
Seller identity and bank account
Contract party, invoice header and receiving account should be the same company.
Inspection and objection procedure
Agree the inspector, timing and objection window, then follow them to the letter.
Deposit wordingreturned double 7/12
Decide whether you pay earnest money (dingjin, returned double on seller default) or an advance payment, and say so in both languages.
Destination-market compliance
Write in the certifications your market requires (CE, UL) and who must issue them.
Quality standard in the contract
Name a measurable standard: a GB or EN number, capacity, material grade. "Good quality" is not a standard.
Late-delivery damages
Agree a realistic rate, around 20% of the price. Object in writing if the seller tries to change it later.
Jurisdiction and governing law
Make a chosen court "exclusive". Choosing Chinese law does not exclude CISG unless you say so.
Payment security
Verify any change of bank details by phone with a known contact.
Show the data
| Contract issue | Hurt the buyer | Helped the buyer | Cases where it hurt | Cases where it helped |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper after things go wrong | 5 | 9 | 15, 51, 67, 78, 107 | 12, 36, 72, 76, 79, 101, 116, 120, 133 |
| Lawyer-fee clause | 6 | 3 | 52, 87, 110, 118, 120, 124 | 78, 113, 128 |
| Seller identity and bank account | 3 | 4 | 53, 100, 114 | 57, 96, 112, 118 |
| Inspection and objection procedure | 5 | 1 | 2, 88, 93, 105, 126 | 113 |
| Deposit wording | 1 | 5 | 132 | 37, 47, 50, 69, 96 |
| Destination-market compliance | 0 | 6 | – | 63, 73, 91, 110, 122, 123 |
| Quality standard in the contract | 3 | 2 | 68, 111, 129 | 49, 95 |
| Late-delivery damages | 2 | 3 | 48, 87 | 14, 40, 109 |
| Jurisdiction and governing law | 3 | 0 | 15, 56, 92 | – |
| Payment security | 0 | 1 | – | 57 |
Eight conclusions
- 01 Can a foreign buyer win a lawsuit against a Chinese supplier in a Chinese court? Most foreign buyers who sue a Chinese supplier in a Chinese court win at least part of what they ask for. 82% Of the 107 foreign buyers who sued a mainland Chinese supplier, 88 won all or part of their claim.
- 02 Do most cases get appealed, and do appeals change the result? Most cases end with the first judgment, and most appeals leave it standing. 37/49 Of the 134 cases, 84 ended at first instance. Of the 49 that were appealed, the appeal court upheld 37 and changed 12, some of them in the buyer’s favour.
- 03 How long does a lawsuit against a Chinese supplier take? Getting from filing to a first-instance judgment takes about eight months at the median. 231 days Half of the 76 cases with a recorded filing date had a first-instance judgment within 231 days.
- 04 Can a buyer win a quality dispute against a Chinese supplier? In a quality dispute, photos and emails alone rarely win the case for the buyer. 5/25 When the supplier fought a defective-goods claim, the buyer won outright in only 5 of 25 cases.
- 05 Do quality problems work better as a claim or as a defence? The same quality problem gets further as a defence than as a claim. 6/7 In 7 cases the supplier sued for the price and the buyer pointed to quality problems. In 6 of them the buyer paid less or won outright.
- 06 Which disputes with Chinese suppliers do buyers win most often? Buyers win most often when the supplier took the money and shipped nothing. 42/49 Of the 49 cases where the supplier was paid and never shipped, buyers won 42.
- 07 Can a buyer hold the shareholders of a Chinese supplier personally liable? Most buyers who asked the court to make a shareholder or other individual liable got that ruling. 11/16 Buyers asked for this in 16 cases, and the court agreed in 11.
- 08 Can a buyer recover lawyer fees, or get a deposit back double, from a Chinese supplier? Lawyer fees, and a deposit returned double, both depend on the contract saying so. 2/8 Lawyer fees were claimed in 8 cases and awarded in 2. Each time, the contract provided for them.
The data
All 134 cases
Every row lists the docket numbers, so you can look up the judgment itself. Case catalogue: CSV, English and Chinese
| Buyer | Supplier | Goods and key point | Claim or defence | Outcome for buyer | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1(2012)佛中法民四初字第4、64号 | 2016 | Poland | Foshan, Guangdong | Aluminium profiles Steel and metalsLost profit was awarded in part; the first instance took four years. | Paid, never shipped | $557,105 | 1810 | Partly won |
| 2(2014)浙杭商外初字第41号 | 2016 | United States | Jiande, Zhejiang | Hot-melt glue sticks Chemicals and raw materialsAfter inspecting and taking an SGS certificate, the buyer rejected goods and had to pay the seller's losses. | Defective goods | – | – | Lost and paid the seller |
| 3(2014)金义商外初字第161号 | 2016 | Hong Kong | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Bamboo clips Household goods and stationeryWith partial delivery, the deposit penalty applied pro rata. | Late or partial deliverySeller absent | $13,500 | – | Partly won |
| 4(2015)扬商外初字第00004号 | 2016 | Netherlands | Yangzhou, Jiangsu | Bags Bags and leather goodsA compensation agreement signed by the actual factory added a second party to pursue. | Defective goods | $27,346 | 356 | Buyer won |
| 5(2015)浙甬商外终字第30号 | 2016 | United States | Ningbo, Zhejiang | T-head bolts Steel and metalsRework costs claimed without matching records and payments were rejected. | Defective goodsUpheld on appeal | $398,131 | – | Buyer lost |
| 6(2015)苏商外终字第00007号 | 2016 | South Korea | Lianyungang, Jiangsu | Frozen garlic Food and agricultureLosses from extreme market swings in farm produce were not recoverable from the seller. | OtherUpheld on appeal | $75,000 | – | Partly won |
| 7(2015)赣民四终字第3号 | 2016 | South Korea | Nanchang, Jiangxi | Jeans Apparel and footwearWith the standard set as "approved pre-production sample", tests not compared to that sample failed. | Defective goodsUpheld on appeal | $412,387 | – | Buyer lost |
| 8(2015)金义商外初字第122号 · (2016)浙07民终1867号 | 2016 | Russia | Yiwu, Zhejiang | ATVs Vehicles and auto partsA distributor's purchase targets became the seller's counterclaim. | OtherUpheld on appeal | $360,221 | – | Partly won |
| 9(2015)金义商外初字第266号 · (2016)浙07民终3590号 | 2016 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Garments Apparel and footwearThe buyer had signed an IOU, but a handwriting examination showed the seller had added a digit to the amount; the appeal court dismissed the whole claim. | Disputed amount or quantityChanged on appeal | $195,588 | – | Buyer won |
| 10(2016)冀民终294号 | 2016 | UAE | Shijiazhuang, Hebei | Chemicals Chemicals and raw materialsWhether a payment is a deposit or a prepayment decides whether it can come back double. | Paid, never shippedChanged on appeal | $154,900 | – | Partly won |
| 11(2016)冀民终823号 | 2016 | India | Hengshui, Hebei | Folic acid Chemicals and raw materialsThe exclusive-distribution claim was dismissed at first instance; on appeal the seller was ordered to pay RMB 100,000 of the buyer's losses. | OtherChanged on appeal | $43,382 | – | Partly won |
| 12(2016)吉民终293号 | 2016 | United States | Tieling, Liaoning | Furfural Chemicals and raw materialsAn affiliate that co-signed the repayment agreement became jointly liable; a 2006 prepayment was refunded in 2016. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $973,333 | – | Buyer won |
| 13(2016)浙02民初44号 | 2016 | United States | Ningbo, Zhejiang | Solar lights Lighting and solarThe buyer won USD 1.16m, but the seller was already in bankruptcy. | Late or partial delivery | $1,161,607 | – | Buyer won |
| 14(2016)浙0782民初01999号 | 2016 | Not stated | Dongyang, Zhejiang | Knitwear Apparel and footwearA contract clause fixing compensation at 20% for late delivery was applied as written. | Late or partial deliverySeller absent | $47,588 | 209 | Buyer won |
| 15(2016)浙0782民初14878号 | 2016 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Garments Apparel and footwearPaying while denying the debt was treated as admitting it. | "I was not the buyer" | $96,691 | 108 | Buyer lost |
| 16(2016)浙0782民初1863号 · (2016)浙07民终3236号 | 2016 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Garments Apparel and footwearProof of payment to the middleman defeated the supplier's direct claim. | "I was not the buyer"Upheld on appeal | $110,294 | – | Buyer won |
| 17(2016)浙0782民初9577号 | 2016 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Seamless underwear Apparel and footwearNo signature on any order: the seller could not tie the debt to the buyer. | "I was not the buyer" | $143,629 | 100 | Buyer won |
| 18(2016)粤0391民初567号 | 2016 | Brazil | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Electronics Consumer electronicsA USD prepayment earned interest at a USD lending rate. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $33,600 | – | Buyer won |
| 19(2016)苏民终493号 | 2016 | Australia | Changshu, Jiangsu | Zirconium tubes Steel and metalsThe buyer lost at first instance and won on appeal; the seller's offer to replace goods was an admission. | Defective goodsChanged on appeal | $341,299 | – | Buyer won |
| 20(2014)城商初字第790号 · (2017)鲁02民终8986号 | 2017 | Russia | Qingdao, Shandong | Steel structures Steel and metals"Delivered to your nominee" failed without the buyer's written nomination. | Late or partial deliveryUpheld on appeal | $220,138 | – | Partly won |
| 21(2014)浙台商外初字第6号 · (2016)浙民终208号 | 2017 | Italy | Taizhou, Zhejiang | Solar products Lighting and solarOn appeal the amount fell from EUR 3.04m to EUR 0.72m based on the statement of account. | Disputed amount or quantityChanged on appeal | $3,495,061 | 578 | Partly won |
| 22(2015)杭西商外初字第145号 | 2017 | Thailand | Hangzhou, Zhejiang | Private-label stationery Household goods and stationeryApproved reference samples settled the quality dispute; only the defective lines were avoided. | Defective goods | $50,869 | 735 | Partly won |
| 23(2016)浙01民初972号 | 2017 | Hong Kong | Hangzhou, Zhejiang | Electrical goods Home appliancesA quality counterclaim offset most of the price owed. | Quality defence or counterclaim | $13,040 | 322 | Partly won |
| 24(2016)浙0782民初11258号 · (2016)浙07民终5602号 | 2017 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Lighting Lighting and solarAn interpreter who signed orders in their own name was treated as the buyer, not the foreign client. | "I was not the buyer"Upheld on appeal | $26,038 | 72 | Buyer won |
| 25(2016)浙0782民初5216号 · (2017)浙07民终1130号 | 2017 | Not stated | Shangrao, Jiangxi | Lighting Lighting and solarThe seller could not show the defendants were the buyer; claim dismissed. | "I was not the buyer"Upheld on appeal | $235,294 | 222 | Buyer won |
| 26(2016)粤03民终17178号 | 2017 | Netherlands | Shenzhen, Guangdong | TV sets Home appliancesCover purchase right after avoidance supported damages under CISG Arts. 74-75. | Late or partial deliveryUpheld on appeal | $111,880 | – | Partly won |
| 27(2016)鄂01民初1137号 | 2017 | Hong Kong | Wuhan, Hubei | Textiles Textiles and fabricsA third party taking on the debt did not release the original buyer. | "I was not the buyer" | $10,686,252 | 330 | Buyer lost |
| 28(2016)闽民终1439号 | 2017 | South Korea | Ningde, Fujian | Seafood Food and agricultureLetters of credit proved the sale; the "only an agent" defence failed. | "I was not the buyer"Upheld on appeal | $403,272 | – | Buyer lost |
| 29(2016)鲁01民初1478号 | 2017 | South Korea | Jinan, Shandong | Chemical raw materials Chemicals and raw materialsDestination-country test reports and disposal invoices recovered costs as well as price. | Defective goodsSeller absent | $205,479 | 184 | Buyer won |
| 30(2017)京02民终8036号 | 2017 | Russia | Beijing | Valves Machinery and componentsA contract with the company stamp, signed by an employee, bound the company. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $23,000 | – | Buyer won |
| 31(2017)津01民初38号 · (2017)津民终484号 | 2017 | UAE | Beijing | Glass jars PackagingA firm deadline in a lawyer's letter set up termination. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $40,068 | 172 | Buyer won |
| 32(2017)浙0110民初5719号 | 2017 | India | Hangzhou, Zhejiang | Taffeta fabric Textiles and fabricsThe seller admitted fault for the delay in an email. | Late or partial deliverySeller absent | $20,000 | 240 | Buyer won |
| 33(2017)浙02民初459号 | 2017 | Saudi Arabia | Ningbo, Zhejiang | Electrical appliances Home appliancesAgainst a sole-trader factory, the owner was liable for any shortfall. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $179,604 | 136 | Buyer won |
| 34(2017)浙0402民初1170号 | 2017 | Slovakia | Jiaxing, Zhejiang | Garments Apparel and footwearMoney paid to an export agent: the agent was not liable, the factory was. | Paid, never shipped | $15,298 | – | Buyer won |
| 35(2017)浙0402民初1173号 | 2017 | Slovakia | Jiaxing, Zhejiang | Garments Apparel and footwearLate delivery of seasonal goods was a fundamental breach. | Late or partial deliverySeller absent | $12,094 | – | Buyer won |
| 36(2017)浙0782民初5265号 | 2017 | Iran | Foshan, Guangdong | Air conditioners Home appliancesRising material costs did not excuse non-performance; a written refund promise did the work. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | – | – | Buyer won |
| 37(2017)粤0391民初2260号 | 2017 | United Kingdom | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Custom equipment Machinery and componentsPayment to a Hong Kong account did not stop the mainland company being the seller. | Paid, never shipped | $35,056 | 136 | Buyer won |
| 38(2017)苏04民初57号 | 2017 | United States | Zibo, Shandong | Container liners PackagingA quality issue in two orders did not excuse payment for the other seven. | Quality defence or counterclaim | $541,634 | 189 | Partly won |
| 39(2017)鲁民终120号 | 2017 | UAE | Qingdao, Shandong | Prebaked anodes Chemicals and raw materialsAn embargo made performance impossible; the buyer recovered USD 1.88m paid. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $1,884,000 | – | Buyer won |
| 40(2016)浙0782民初16893号 | 2018 | Poland | Xuzhou, Jiangsu | Lighting Lighting and solarThe buyer capped a high penalty clause at 30% of price itself; the court agreed. | Late or partial delivery | $49,277 | 491 | Buyer won |
| 41(2016)粤0391民初2049号 | 2018 | United States | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Hoverboards Vehicles and auto partsThird-party IP claims in the US let the buyer avoid the contract under CISG Art. 42. | Other | $285,001 | 775 | Buyer won |
| 42(2016)闽民终663号 | 2018 | Greece | Quanzhou, Fujian | Bags Bags and leather goodsPayment lost to a wrong account: costs were split by fault. | OtherUpheld on appeal | $28,560 | – | Buyer won |
| 43(2017)沪0113民再1号 | 2018 | Philippines | Shanghai | Plywood Building materials and furnitureA reconciliation statement was the best evidence of the refund amount. | Late or partial deliveryRetrial | $221,187 | – | Buyer won |
| 44(2017)浙02民初390号 · (2017)浙民终789号 | 2018 | United States | Ningbo, Zhejiang | Eyebrow stamps and foot files Beauty and personal careA seller absent at trial could not raise a new "wrong party" defence on appeal. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appealSeller absent | $8,863 | 212 | Buyer won |
| 45(2017)浙0402民初6309号 · (2018)浙04民终1238号 | 2018 | Not stated | Jiaxing, Zhejiang | Fasteners Steel and metalsThe documents always named an individual, so the individual had to refund. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $73,529 | 191 | Buyer won |
| 46(2017)浙0782民初19603号 | 2018 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Second-hand clothing Apparel and footwearA written termination notice lets interest start earlier. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $33,456 | 81 | Buyer won |
| 47(2017)浙0782民初19619号 | 2018 | Jordan | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Leather cases Bags and leather goodsDeposit returned double; deposit penalty and liquidated damages cannot be stacked. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $19,853 | 215 | Buyer won |
| 48(2017)粤0605民初20313号 | 2018 | India | Foshan, Guangdong | TV sets Home appliancesSilence after the seller rewrote the penalty in a later letter counted as agreement. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $40,717 | 92 | Buyer won |
| 49(2018)冀民终704号 | 2018 | Spain | Cangzhou, Hebei | Seamless pipes Steel and metalsThird-party tests before and after delivery proved welded pipe was sold as seamless. | Defective goodsUpheld on appeal | $88,033 | – | Buyer won |
| 50(2018)浙0782民初2230号 | 2018 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Cotton gloves Protective glovesA deposit clause in the PI meant double return when the seller failed to deliver. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $20,000 | 173 | Buyer won |
| 51(2018)浙0782民初2690号 | 2018 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Stationery Household goods and stationeryAfter signing a statement of the debt, "someone else bought it" failed. | "I was not the buyer" | $106,715 | 256 | Buyer lost |
| 52(2018)粤0391民初1159号 | 2018 | Hungary | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Starters Vehicles and auto partsThe buyer could not prove its balance payment, so the claim failed. | Paid, never shipped | $23,342 | – | Buyer lost |
| 53(2018)粤0606民初5189号 | 2018 | Germany | Foshan, Guangdong | Electrical appliances Home appliancesThe buyer sued the export agent on the PI header, not the factory; the claim failed. | Paid, never shipped | $19,412 | 207 | Buyer lost |
| 54(2018)粤0606民初7794号 | 2018 | United States | Foshan, Guangdong | Furniture Building materials and furnitureUnconfirmed stock orders did not bind the buyer; only delivered goods were payable. | Quality defence or counterclaim | $53,345 | 215 | Partly won |
| 55(2018)豫民终798号 | 2018 | Jordan | Zhengzhou, Henan | Biscuits Food and agricultureA "security deposit" not agreed as earnest money could not be forfeited by the seller. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $40,219 | – | Buyer won |
| 56 | 2019 | Hong Kong | Suzhou, Jiangsu | Electrical goods Home appliancesA non-exclusive Hong Kong jurisdiction clause did not stop a mainland court. | Procedure or jurisdictionUpheld on appeal | – | – | Buyer lost |
| 57(2016)苏04民初265号 · (2018)苏民终999号 | 2019 | Mozambique | Changzhou, Jiangsu | Not stated Not statedThe seller claimed its email was hacked; the court still found it received the money paid to its affiliate. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $119,020 | 593 | Buyer won |
| 58(2017)湘01民初4450号 | 2019 | UAE | Changsha, Hunan | Steel pipes Steel and metalsA fake mill test certificate (MTC) made fundamental breach easy to find. | Defective goods | $240,758 | 488 | Buyer won |
| 59(2017)粤0391民初2288号 | 2019 | Turkey | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Tablets and phones Consumer electronicsThe English word "deposit" was translated as dingjin (earnest money); the refund was single, not double. | Paid, never shipped | $354,049 | 719 | Buyer won |
| 60(2017)苏02民初259号 | 2019 | Canada | Wuxi, Jiangsu | Steel Steel and metalsEach order was examined separately; the buyer won on some orders only. | Short quantity | $351,487 | 977 | Partly won |
| 61(2018)津01民初410号 · (2019)津民终90号 | 2019 | Romania | Tianjin | Steel Steel and metalsA few days' late prepayment did not let the seller refuse delivery without a CISG Art. 63 grace period. | Paid, never shippedChanged on appeal | $202,086 | – | Buyer won |
| 62(2018)粤0391民初2483号 | 2019 | Denmark | Heyuan, Guangdong | Heating appliances Home appliancesA refund for defective units was awarded even 24 months after delivery (an outlier). | Defective goodsSeller absent | $53,273 | 469 | Buyer won |
| 63(2018)粤0391民初2728号 | 2019 | United States | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Hoverboards Vehicles and auto partsFake UL marks were a fundamental breach; an affiliated group company was jointly liable. | Certification or compliance failure | $85,700 | – | Buyer won |
| 64(2018)苏02民初280号 | 2019 | Turkey | Wuxi, Jiangsu | Stainless tubes Steel and metalsA USD 5,320 order received a full CISG analysis from an intermediate court. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $5,320 | 547 | Buyer won |
| 65(2018)苏02民初283号 | 2019 | Japan | Cangzhou, Hebei | Machine tools Machinery and componentsWithout an agreed interest rate, only the benchmark rate was awarded. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $24,265 | 173 | Buyer won |
| 66(2018)鲁02民初1357号 | 2019 | Iran | Qingdao, Shandong | Colour-coated steel (PPGI) Steel and metalsSole shareholder held jointly liable for the refund. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $127,513 | 302 | Buyer won |
| 67(2018)鲁13民初705号 | 2019 | India | Linyi, Shandong | Wood panels Building materials and furnitureSigning a notarised debt confirmation made the buyer a debtor. | "I was not the buyer" | $170,430 | 213 | Buyer lost |
| 68(2019)粤0606民初4315号 | 2019 | South Korea | Foshan, Guangdong | Polishing line Machinery and componentsNo performance spec in the contract: the buyer lost and had to pay the balance. | Defective goods | $231,349 | 243 | Buyer lost |
| 69(2019)闽民终578号 | 2019 | Japan | Zhangzhou, Fujian | Dried plums Food and agricultureAn extra time limit under CISG Art. 47, then avoidance; the deposit was returned double. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $83,767 | – | Buyer won |
| 70(2019)闽民终819号 | 2019 | Ireland | Quanzhou, Fujian | Christmas goods Household goods and stationerySuing the person who actually ran the Hong Kong shell seller in mainland China worked. | Late or partial deliveryUpheld on appeal | $19,203 | – | Buyer won |
| 71(2019)鲁0211民初6066号 | 2019 | Uzbekistan | Qingdao, Shandong | Polyester chips Chemicals and raw materialsPaid, nothing shipped, seller absent: full refund by judgment. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $21,560 | 171 | Buyer won |
| 72(2019)鲁02民初272号 | 2019 | Hungary | Qingdao, Shandong | Plastic film PackagingThe seller admitted defects by email and agreed to refund; that was enough. | Defective goodsSeller absent | $29,690 | 247 | Buyer won |
| 73(2017)粤0391民初2264号 · (2019)粤03民终3155号 | 2020 | Hungary | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Christmas lights Lighting and solarLights that failed EU CE rules: contract avoided and price refunded, despite pre-shipment checks. | Certification or compliance failureUpheld on appeal | $152,721 | – | Buyer won |
| 74(2018)粤民终1424号 | 2020 | United States | Chaozhou, Guangdong | Women's shoes Apparel and footwearChoosing "Chinese law" in the contract did not exclude CISG. | Defective goodsChanged on appeal | – | – | Partly won |
| 75(2018)苏民终1149号 | 2020 | South Africa | Suzhou, Jiangsu | Dyed fabric Textiles and fabricsAdmitting receipt at first instance and then alleging forged bills of lading on appeal did not work. | Disputed amount or quantityChanged on appeal | $398,410 | – | Buyer lost |
| 76(2019)冀01民初399号 | 2020 | UAE | Handan, Hebei | Metal materials Steel and metalsEnvironmental production limits did not excuse the refund; extra costs not agreed were refused. | Paid, never shipped | $142,050 | – | Buyer won |
| 77(2019)浙0782民初1635号 · (2020)浙07民终403号 | 2020 | United Kingdom | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Shirts Apparel and footwearChanging specifications mid-order gave the seller a delay defence; both sides were partly liable. | Late or partial deliveryUpheld on appeal | $15,378 | 313 | Partly won |
| 78(2019)浙0782民初17200号 | 2020 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Small commodities Household goods and stationeryA signed payment agreement fixed the debt; lawyer fees not named in it were refused. | "I was not the buyer" | $68,997 | 222 | Buyer lost |
| 79(2019)浙0782民初21280号 | 2020 | Not stated | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Smoking accessories Household goods and stationeryA signed IOU from the seller was the cheapest and strongest evidence. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $13,258 | – | Buyer won |
| 80(2019)浙0782民初7167号 | 2020 | South Korea | Yiwu, Zhejiang | Luggage Bags and leather goodsThe seller's written refund promise was enforced; an extreme daily penalty was reduced. | Other | $38,531 | 325 | Buyer won |
| 81(2019)浙民终727号 | 2020 | Italy | Hangzhou, Zhejiang | Bearings Machinery and componentsA conditional debt waiver lapsed when the buyer missed the condition; quality losses were offset. | Quality defence or counterclaimChanged on appeal | $2,560,410 | – | Partly won |
| 82(2019)粤0391民初1932号 | 2020 | France | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Electronics Consumer electronicsA quality claim brought by the buyer's insurer years later failed without timely notice and inspection. | Defective goods | $378,863 | 549 | Buyer lost |
| 83(2019)粤0391民初2540号 | 2020 | Canada | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Cable-assembly moulds Machinery and componentsMoulds the buyer paid for belonged to the buyer; the court ordered them returned. | Other | $35,984 | 381 | Buyer won |
| 84(2019)粤0391民初289号 | 2020 | UAE | Shenzhen, Guangdong | TV panels Consumer electronicsThe buyer's own debit note, even legalised, was not proof of defects. | Defective goods | $148,000 | – | Buyer lost |
| 85(2019)粤0391民初636号 | 2020 | United States | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Solar generators Lighting and solarEven without a written standard, CISG Art. 35 fitness for purpose supported a USD 1.26m recall award. | Defective goods | $3,004,094 | – | Partly won |
| 86(2019)赣01民初541号 | 2020 | Uruguay | Nanchang, Jiangxi | Garments Apparel and footwearSample or development fees the seller invented later could not be set off. | Late or partial delivery | $41,700 | 155 | Buyer won |
| 87(2019)赣01民初745号 | 2020 | Uruguay | Nanchang, Jiangxi | Garments Apparel and footwearWith no penalty clause in the PI, the buyer got its prepayment back but not its losses or lawyer fees. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $111,344 | 177 | Buyer won |
| 88(2019)鲁0211民初14331号 | 2020 | Belgium | Qingdao, Shandong | Conveyor belts Machinery and componentsThe contract's own avoidance test was not performed and the goods were used; the buyer lost. | Defective goods | $269,746 | 200 | Buyer lost |
| 89(2020)冀01民初234号 | 2020 | Not stated | Shijiazhuang, Hebei | Stone Building materials and furnitureA small stone order was refunded at first instance; small claims are worth bringing. | Paid, never shipped | $7,419 | 53 | Buyer won |
| 90(2020)浙02民初1460号 | 2021 | Japan | Ningbo, Zhejiang | Disposable masks Masks and medical PPETerminating on suspicion of bad test papers, without an independent inspection, led to an order to complete the deal. | Defective goods | $75,600 | 249 | Buyer lost |
| 91(2020)粤20民初120号 | 2021 | Australia | Zhongshan, Guangdong | Medical masks Masks and medical PPEMasks rejected by Chinese customs inspection gave the buyer clear grounds to terminate and recover in full. | Certification or compliance failure | $1,875,000 | 364 | Buyer won |
| 92(2020)豫民终496号 | 2021 | Belgium | Zhengzhou, Henan | Chemicals Chemicals and raw materialsA jurisdiction objection not raised within the defence period was lost. | Procedure or jurisdictionUpheld on appeal | – | – | Buyer lost |
| 93(2020)陕01民初662号 | 2021 | Italy | Xi'an, Shaanxi | Steel pipes Steel and metalsThe contract's own inspection terms limited later quality claims; the buyer lost. | Defective goods | $554,721 | 440 | Buyer lost |
| 94(2020)鲁02民初872号 | 2021 | Canada | Qingdao, Shandong | Transmission towers Steel and metalsThe buyer's self-prepared customs declarations did not prove the price; quality claims went to a separate case. | Quality defence or counterclaim | $7,557,278 | 545 | Buyer lost |
| 95(2020)鲁民终947号 | 2021 | Serbia | Jinan, Shandong | Production equipment Machinery and componentsThe buyer counterclaimed and won back its prepayment and USD 7,000 lawyer fees. | Quality defence or counterclaimChanged on appeal | $95,000 | – | Buyer won |
| 96(2021)冀民终553号 | 2021 | Panama | Shijiazhuang, Hebei | Textiles Textiles and fabricsThe company named on the PI and paid the deposit was liable, and paid the deposit back double. | Paid, never shippedChanged on appeal | $250,000 | – | Buyer won |
| 97(2021)浙10民初75号 | 2021 | Canada | Taizhou, Zhejiang | Home decor Building materials and furnitureSuing the sole shareholder alongside the company brought personal assets into enforcement. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $200,058 | 295 | Buyer won |
| 98(2021)粤03民终11125号 | 2021 | Not stated | Shenzhen, Hong Kong / mainland | Dashcams Consumer electronicsShareholder liability for a Hong Kong seller is judged under Hong Kong law; the PRC one-person-company rule did not apply. | Defective goodsUpheld on appeal | $717,377 | – | Partly won |
| 99(2021)粤03民终4037号 | 2021 | Not stated | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Digital products Consumer electronicsThe buyer defended and counterclaimed; a single IOU was not enough for the seller. | OtherUpheld on appeal | $51,823 | – | Buyer won |
| 100(2021)粤0606民初11724号 | 2021 | Singapore | Not stated | Ceramic tiles Building materials and furnitureThe buyer sued the individual it dealt with, not the seller on the PI; the whole claim was dismissed. | Paid, never shipped | $63,706 | 120 | Buyer lost |
| 101(2021)鄂08民初71号 | 2021 | Hong Kong | Jingmen, Hubei | Face masks Masks and medical PPEA deduction agreement signed after a quality dispute defeated the seller's claim. | Quality defence or counterclaim | $90,000 | 139 | Buyer won |
| 102(2021)鲁0211民初3809号 | 2021 | Thailand | Qingdao, Shandong | Sodium citrate Chemicals and raw materialsOnly photocopies of photos as quality evidence: the claim failed. | Defective goods | $27,500 | 90 | Buyer lost |
| 103(2021)鲁02民初1280号 | 2021 | Hong Kong | Qingdao, Shandong | Steel structures Steel and metalsA seller replying "please send your refund account" had agreed to refund. | Paid, never shipped | $100,000 | 211 | Buyer won |
| 104(2021)鲁02民终10839号 | 2021 | Not stated | Qingdao, Shandong | Electric vehicles Vehicles and auto partsA final written demand with a deadline, then termination, made the refund claim solid. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $58,004 | – | Buyer won |
| 105(2021)鲁02民终3672号 | 2021 | South Korea | Qingdao, Shandong | Metal products Steel and metalsNo objection at the buyer's own inspection; later quality complaints were not accepted. | Defective goodsUpheld on appeal | $30,000 | – | Partly won |
| 106(2021)鲁民终337号 | 2021 | United States | Qingdao, Shandong | Graphite Chemicals and raw materialsThe seller's one-sided exchange-loss calculations were not binding. | Disputed amount or quantityUpheld on appeal | – | – | Buyer won |
| 107(2021)黑07民初15号 | 2021 | South Korea | Yichun, Heilongjiang | Wild vegetables Food and agricultureSigned reconciliation letters defeated the buyer's "paid in full" defence. | Disputed amount or quantity | $71,815 | – | Buyer lost |
| 108(2020)粤0191民初20471号 · (2022)粤01民终5133号 | 2022 | Spain | Guangzhou, Guangdong | KN95 masks Masks and medical PPEAgainst a one-deal company, holding the sole shareholder jointly liable was the route to recovery. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $260,929 | – | Buyer won |
| 109(2021)浙02民初1653号 | 2022 | United States | Ningbo, Zhejiang | Nitrile gloves Protective glovesThe seller's own refund schedule proved the debt; a 20% liquidated-damages clause was enforced. | Paid, never shipped | $1,156,764 | 339 | Buyer won |
| 110(2021)浙02民初824号 · (2022)浙民终1205号 | 2022 | Germany | Ningbo, Zhejiang | Face masks Masks and medical PPEThe seller's emails agreeing to a refund were the key evidence. Under CISG the court refused lawyer fees. | Late or partial deliveryUpheld on appeal | $1,271,175 | – | Buyer won |
| 111(2021)浙0702民初3684号 | 2022 | United States | Jinhua, Zhejiang | KN95 masks Masks and medical PPETest reports that could not be tied to the shipment, and to the wrong standard, were rejected. | Defective goods | $210,000 | 472 | Buyer lost |
| 112(2021)粤0191民初1350号 | 2022 | United States | Guangzhou, Hong Kong / mainland | Face masks Masks and medical PPEEvidence that a Hong Kong receiving company and a Guangzhou factory were one operation made both liable. | Defective goods | $1,738,405 | 705 | Buyer won |
| 113(2021)粤0191民初17578号 · (2022)粤01民终24628号 | 2022 | Singapore | Guangzhou, Guangdong | Dry wipe canisters Household goods and stationeryJoint SGS sampling, chat records and a lawyer-fee clause gave the buyer a near-full recovery for short filling. | Short quantityUpheld on appeal | $252,191 | 377 | Buyer won |
| 114(2021)粤0191民初3606号 | 2022 | South Korea | Foshan, Guangdong | KN95 masks Masks and medical PPEThe buyer's own payment default reversed the case, and one defendant turned out to be only a consultant. | Paid, never shipped | $2,941,176 | – | Buyer lost |
| 115(2021)粤0391民初8901号 | 2022 | Japan | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Protective equipment Masks and medical PPEAn undelivered prepayment was refunded with interest above the benchmark rate; the shareholder was joined. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $464,400 | 109 | Buyer won |
| 116(2021)鲁01民初1244号 · (2021)鲁民终2326号 | 2022 | Canada | Jinan, Shandong | Potassium iodide Chemicals and raw materialsThe seller's written admission of serious quality problems secured the refund. | Defective goodsUpheld on appeal | $204,425 | 96 | Partly won |
| 117(2021)鲁01民初1498号 | 2022 | South Korea | Jinan, Shandong | Nitrile gloves Protective glovesThe buyer could not prove it had paid in full, so it could not prove the seller was in breach. | Paid, never shipped | $243,765 | 275 | Buyer lost |
| 118(2021)鲁02民初2037号 | 2022 | Japan | Qingdao, Shandong | Ginger and onions Food and agricultureWhen an individual exports under a company's name, sue the company that signed and received the money. | Paid, never shipped | $113,590 | 255 | Buyer won |
| 119(2021)鲁07民初151号 | 2022 | Japan | Shouguang, Shandong | Nitrile gloves Protective glovesA 1%-per-day penalty was cut down by the court; the deposit was refunded. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $111,588 | 355 | Buyer won |
| 120(2022)粤1971民初5418号 | 2022 | Belize | Dongguan, Guangdong | Nitrile gloves Protective glovesA signed refund agreement turned the lawsuit into simple debt collection. | Late or partial delivery | $1,101,346 | 155 | Buyer won |
| 121(2022)京04民初294号 | 2023 | United States | Beijing | Nitrile gloves Protective glovesThe factory admitted on a video call that it shipped blended gloves; recorded admissions carried the case. | Defective goodsSeller absent | $945,000 | 393 | Buyer won |
| 122(2022)沪0112民初27976号 | 2023 | Belgium | Shanghai | Face masks Masks and medical PPEInvalid CE certificates meant the masks could not be sold in Belgium; about 96% of the refund was awarded. | Certification or compliance failure | $3,073,090 | 277 | Buyer won |
| 123(2022)粤0191民初9753号 | 2023 | Barbados | Guangzhou, Guangdong | Face masks Masks and medical PPECE certificates from an unauthorised body were a breach. A buyer who bought through a disclosed agent could sue the factory directly. | Certification or compliance failureSeller absent | $653,560 | 401 | Buyer won |
| 124(2022)粤1971民初29176号 | 2023 | Sweden | Dongguan, Guangdong | Sportswear Apparel and footwearA written termination notice before suing fixed the termination date and interest start. | Paid, never shipped | $314,975 | 133 | Buyer won |
| 125(2022)粤19民终1779号 | 2023 | Norway | Dongguan, Guangdong | Face masks Masks and medical PPEMasks were destroyed at customs for wrong paperwork; the buyer got half back because it did not mitigate. | Certification or compliance failureUpheld on appeal | $155,625 | – | Partly won |
| 126(2022)粤民终3386号 | 2023 | Germany | Guangzhou, Guangdong | Face masks Masks and medical PPEQuality complaints not raised the way the contract required were rejected; the buyer recovered only offset costs. | Late or partial deliveryChanged on appeal | $1,279,412 | – | Partly won |
| 127(2022)鲁14民初108号 | 2023 | Hong Kong | Dezhou, Shandong | Not stated Not statedHong Kong buyer ordered to pay the price plus 1% monthly interest. | Other | $937,212 | 169 | Buyer lost |
| 128(2023)粤0391民初3116号 | 2023 | Malaysia | Shandong | Steel and steel strip Steel and metalsA small claim still won, but lawyer fees were cut to about a third of what was spent. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $13,872 | 149 | Buyer won |
| 129(2023)浙0822民初1648号 | 2024 | Spain | Longyou, Zhejiang | Warning triangles Vehicles and auto partsA quality standard mentioned only in chat (ECE R27) was not part of the contract; the claim failed. | Defective goods | $248,076 | 220 | Buyer lost |
| 130(2023)粤03民终36761号 | 2024 | Not stated | Shenzhen, Guangdong | Gloves Protective glovesSuing the company and its shareholder together worked; "several partners ran it" did not reduce the company's liability. | Paid, never shippedUpheld on appeal | $102,963 | – | Buyer won |
| 131(2024)沪0115民初9930号 | 2024 | Russia | Shanghai | Glass-felt insulation Building materials and furnitureCommon shareholders between buyer and seller did not excuse the seller from refunding. | Paid, never shipped | $193,820 | 190 | Buyer won |
| 132(2024)浙0281民初6186号 | 2025 | South Korea | Yuyao, Zhejiang | Nitrile gloves Protective glovesThe buyer's own signed statement that unpaid money would belong to the seller decided the case against it. | Defective goods | $303,167 | – | Buyer lost |
| 133(2017)京0105民初38827号 | – | Not stated | Heze, Shandong | Potassium sulphate Chemicals and raw materialsA settlement agreement signed first made the lawsuit simple. | Paid, never shippedSeller absent | $6,708 | – | Buyer won |
| 134 | – | Spain | Nantong, Jiangsu | Gauze Masks and medical PPEAfter approving samples and shipment in writing, the buyer could not terminate over minor defects. | Defective goods | $84,031 | – | Buyer lost |
Amounts are the buyer's claim (or the seller's claim, for cases where the buyer was sued), converted at about 6.8 CNY and 1.15 EUR per USD. "Days" counts from filing to first-instance judgment where the judgment gives the filing date.
Method and limits
How we built this
Where the cases come from
We searched several full-text legal databases for cases involving an “international sale of goods contract dispute” that reached a final judgment, merged the results, and read all 336 in full. We kept two kinds of case: a buyer outside mainland China suing a mainland supplier (107 cases), and a buyer sued by a mainland supplier who defended (27 cases), with judgments from 2016 to 2025. The search ran to November 2026. The latest judgment we found is from 2025, because judgments are often published a year or more after they are handed down. The first-instance and appeal judgments in one dispute count as one case.
What is missing
- Disputes that settled, were withdrawn or went to arbitration have no published judgment, so they are not here.
- Sale disputes filed under a different cause of action are not included.
- Many cases have only one instance published, so we cannot always tell whether there was an appeal.
How to read the numbers
- “Won” means the court granted the buyer’s main claim. “Partly won” means the award was clearly cut, or only some of the claims succeeded.
- Groups of fewer than five cases show counts, not percentages.
- The eight conclusions are our reading as practising lawyers. The data describes what these judgments decided. It does not show that any one factor caused an outcome, and it cannot predict how your case will go.
- Amounts are converted to US dollars and are approximate.
- Products are sorted into 17 categories by the goods named in the judgment. Where the judgment does not name the goods, the case is “Not stated”.
- The instance is the highest one on record. A case with only a first-instance judgment may still have been appealed, with the appeal judgment unpublished.
- A November 2026 review of the appeal judgments corrected three outcomes: case 9 from lost to won, case 10 from won to partly won, and case 11 from lost to partly won.
Cases by year of judgment
- Buyer won
- Partly won
- Buyer lost
- Lost and paid the seller
Fewer judgments appear after 2022, most likely because fewer were published.
Show the data
| Year | Cases | Buyer won | Partly won | Buyer lost | Lost and paid the seller |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | 19 | 9 | 6 | 3 | 1 |
| 2017 | 20 | 12 | 6 | 2 | 0 |
| 2018 | 16 | 12 | 1 | 3 | 0 |
| 2019 | 17 | 13 | 1 | 3 | 0 |
| 2020 | 17 | 8 | 4 | 5 | 0 |
| 2021 | 18 | 9 | 2 | 7 | 0 |
| 2022 | 13 | 9 | 1 | 3 | 0 |
| 2023 | 8 | 5 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| 2024 | 3 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| 2025 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
Our team coded every case. This report is general information, not legal advice.
How to cite
Kelly Zhang, “China supply chain disputes: the international buyer’s report” (judgments 2016–2025), version 2026-11-13, https://kellyzhanglaw.com/en/report/china-supplier-lawsuits
The charts, findings and case catalogue are licensed CC BY 4.0. You are free to quote and republish them; please credit us and link to this page. Case catalogue: CSV, English and Chinese. For the full underlying data, contact us.