Cases
I act for clients in 18 countries and 20 industries on contracts and disputes with Chinese suppliers, from consumer goods to machinery and medical devices.
- United States
- Australia
- Canada
- United Kingdom
- Germany
- Netherlands
- Italy
- Sweden
- United Arab Emirates
- Spain
- Mexico
- Singapore
- Japan
- France
- Israel
- India
- Colombia
- Romania
- Kitchen and tableware
- Consumer electronics
- Pet products
- Sports and outdoor
- Beauty and cosmetics
- Children's products
- Apparel
- Furniture
- Personal mobility
- Industrial equipment
- Lighting
- Personal care appliances
- Small kitchen appliances
- Solar and energy
- Water treatment
- Chemicals
- Medical products
- Construction machinery
- Hygiene products
- Automotive parts
All cases are anonymised, with no client names or identifying details.
Representative cases
2026
- NNN agreement
Kitchenware
New York United States→Ningbo ZhejiangHave the NNN signed by the factory that will actually make your product, not only the trading company you deal with, and make the Chinese text the governing version. If a dispute arises, the Chinese judicial authorities will read the Chinese text and can only hold liable the company that signed.
- NNN agreement
Sportswear
Los Angeles United States→Quanzhou FujianAgree that disputes are decided by the Chinese judicial authorities, and set a fixed sum the factory must pay for each breach. A foreign judgment is hard to enforce in China, and without a fixed sum you would have to prove your actual loss, which is rarely possible once a design has been copied.
- Tooling agreement
Injection molds for pet products
Chicago United States→Dongguan GuangdongPut mold ownership in a signed agreement, not only on the invoice: list each mold, have it marked with your company name, and give yourself the right to collect it on notice. Factories often refuse to release molds, and an invoice alone is weak proof.
- Product development agreement
Portable espresso machines
Milan Italy→Ningbo ZhejiangAgree in writing, before work starts, that you own the design, drawings, firmware and source code. Under Chinese copyright law, commissioned work belongs to the developer unless the contract says otherwise, so silence works against you.
- Manufacturing agreement
Outdoor furniture
Austin United States→Foshan GuangdongBefore mass production, both sides sign off a golden sample and a written specification, and the contract says who inspects, when, and which sampling standard (for example AQL 2.5) decides pass or fail. Most quality disputes start because nobody fixed what “acceptable” meant.
- Demand letter
Yoga mats
Houston United States→Ningbo Zhejiang- Issue
- Non-delivery after deposit
- Amount
- USD 50–200k
- Result
- Full amount recovered
Send the letter before you pay anything more. It should set out the facts, the exact amount or action you require, a deadline (usually 7 to 14 days), and what follows if it is missed, such as arbitration or a court claim with an asset freeze. Suppliers react to specific consequences, not complaints.
- Dispute resolution
Solar inverters
Melbourne Australia→Shenzhen Guangdong- Issue
- Defective or wrong goods
- Forum
- CIETAC arbitration
- Amount
- USD 500k–1m
- Result
- Award obtained
Before you use, resell or return the goods, keep samples and get an independent inspection report. Once the goods are gone, the supplier will say the defects were caused on your side.
- Manufacturing agreement
Stainless steel water bottles
Stockholm Sweden→Yongkang ZhejiangPay in stages tied to events you can verify: deposit, inspection passed, bill of lading received. Holding back a meaningful part of the price (often 30% or more) until the goods pass inspection is your best leverage if quality slips.
- Manufacturing agreement
Electric bikes
Amsterdam Netherlands→Changzhou JiangsuState that you own the molds, drawings and specifications you pay for, and that the factory may not make your product for anyone else. If the contract is silent, you will have little to rely on when you want to move production.
- Manufacturing agreement
Private-label skincare
Dubai United Arab Emirates→Guangzhou GuangdongBefore mass production, both sides sign off a golden sample and a written specification, and the contract says who inspects, when, and which sampling standard (for example AQL 2.5) decides pass or fail. Most quality disputes start because nobody fixed what “acceptable” meant.
- Manufacturing agreement
Office chairs
Barcelona Spain→Foshan GuangdongPay in stages tied to events you can verify: deposit, inspection passed, bill of lading received. Holding back a meaningful part of the price (often 30% or more) until the goods pass inspection is your best leverage if quality slips.
- Manufacturing agreement
Bluetooth speakers
Monterrey Mexico→Shenzhen GuangdongState that you own the molds, drawings and specifications you pay for, and that the factory may not make your product for anyone else. If the contract is silent, you will have little to rely on when you want to move production.
- Manufacturing agreement
Pet beds
Sydney Australia→Hangzhou ZhejiangBefore mass production, both sides sign off a golden sample and a written specification, and the contract says who inspects, when, and which sampling standard (for example AQL 2.5) decides pass or fail. Most quality disputes start because nobody fixed what “acceptable” meant.
- Tooling agreement
Molds for kitchen storage containers
Toronto Canada→Taizhou ZhejiangPay for tooling under its own agreement, separate from production orders. Otherwise the factory can hold the mold back over an unrelated dispute about a later order.
- Product development agreement
Smart pet feeders
Singapore→Shenzhen GuangdongPay per stage, each with a clear acceptance test, and receive the source files for that stage with each payment. If the project stops halfway, you still hold what you have paid for.
- Demand letter
Camping tents
Osaka Japan→Xiamen Fujian- Issue
- Non-delivery after deposit
- Amount
- USD 50–200k
- Result
- Settled
Gather the evidence first: the contract or proforma invoice, bank payment records, inspection reports and the WeChat or email history. A letter that cites these documents tells the supplier you are ready to go further.
- NNN agreement
Baby strollers
Paris France→Zhongshan GuangdongSpell out what the factory may not do: sell your product or a close variant to others, approach your customers, or use your molds and drawings for anyone else. A general promise not to “circumvent” you is easy to argue around.
Selected cases only. Other 2026 cases are ongoing or confidential and are not listed.
2025
- Manufacturing agreement
Water sports equipment
Melbourne Australia→Dongguan GuangdongPay in stages tied to events you can verify: deposit, inspection passed, bill of lading received. Holding back a meaningful part of the price (often 30% or more) until the goods pass inspection is your best leverage if quality slips.
- Sales agreement
Water purifiers
Tel Aviv Israel→Taizhou ZhejiangName the Incoterm and the exact place of delivery (for example FOB Ningbo). It decides who bears loss in transit, when risk passes to you, and where the goods should be inspected.
- NNN agreement
Children's tableware
Montreal Canada→Xiamen FujianHave the NNN signed by the factory that will actually make your product, not only the trading company you deal with, and make the Chinese text the governing version. If a dispute arises, the Chinese judicial authorities will read the Chinese text and can only hold liable the company that signed.
- NNN agreement
Fragrance
Miami United States→Guangzhou GuangdongAgree that disputes are decided by the Chinese judicial authorities, and set a fixed sum the factory must pay for each breach. A foreign judgment is hard to enforce in China, and without a fixed sum you would have to prove your actual loss, which is rarely possible once a design has been copied.
- Dispute resolution
Chemical products
Mumbai India→Shaoxing ZhejiangStart with the dispute clause: it decides whether you go to arbitration or court, where, and in which language. Then check whether the supplier's assets can be frozen early, which often decides whether a win can actually be collected.
- Tooling agreement
Die-casting molds for e-bike frames
Hamburg Germany→Ningbo ZhejiangAgree the guaranteed shot count, who pays for maintenance and repairs, and how long the mold must be stored if production pauses. These are the points that turn into arguments two years later.
- Product development agreement
Smart speakers
Seattle United States→Shenzhen GuangdongHave the developer confirm in the contract that it has the right to use any parts, code or designs it brings in, and that it will compensate you if it does not. Third-party infringement claims usually land on the brand owner, not the factory.
- Sales agreement
Industrial 3D printers
Stuttgart Germany→ShanghaiSet a deadline for quality complaints and how they must be made (in writing, with photos or an inspection report). A common defence from Chinese suppliers is that the buyer complained too late.
- Demand letter
LED grow lights
Denver United States→Shenzhen Guangdong- Issue
- Defective or wrong goods
- Amount
- USD 50–200k
- Result
- Most of the claim recovered
Decide your next step before the letter goes out, and be ready to take it when the deadline passes. Many cases settle at this stage, but only when the supplier believes the letter.
Selected cases only. Other 2025 cases are not listed.
2024
- NNN agreement
Premium hair dryers
London United Kingdom→Shenzhen GuangdongSpell out what the factory may not do: sell your product or a close variant to others, approach your customers, or use your molds and drawings for anyone else. A general promise not to “circumvent” you is easy to argue around.
- NNN agreement
Electric toothbrushes
Munich Germany→Shenzhen GuangdongHave the NNN signed by the factory that will actually make your product, not only the trading company you deal with, and make the Chinese text the governing version. If a dispute arises, the Chinese judicial authorities will read the Chinese text and can only hold liable the company that signed.
- NNN agreement
Medical devices
Amsterdam Netherlands→ShanghaiAgree that disputes are decided by the Chinese judicial authorities, and set a fixed sum the factory must pay for each breach. A foreign judgment is hard to enforce in China, and without a fixed sum you would have to prove your actual loss, which is rarely possible once a design has been copied.
- Dispute resolution
Excavators
Bogotá Colombia→Yantai Shandong- Issue
- Import dispute
Keep the customs declarations, bill of lading and inspection certificates together. They show when risk passed and whose problem the defect or delay was.
- Dispute resolution
Wet wipes
London United Kingdom→Yiwu Zhejiang- Issue
- Product safety
Safety claims turn on which standard the contract named and what the test reports show. Have the goods tested by an accredited lab against that standard before you make the claim.
- Demand letter
Women's activewear
Toronto Canada→Xiamen Fujian- Issue
- Refund and cancellation
- Amount
- Under USD 50k
- Result
- Full amount recovered
Send the letter before you pay anything more. It should set out the facts, the exact amount or action you require, a deadline (usually 7 to 14 days), and what follows if it is missed, such as arbitration or a court claim with an asset freeze. Suppliers react to specific consequences, not complaints.
Selected cases only. Other 2024 cases are not listed.
2023
- NNN agreement
Cosmetics
Bucharest Romania→Guangzhou GuangdongSpell out what the factory may not do: sell your product or a close variant to others, approach your customers, or use your molds and drawings for anyone else. A general promise not to “circumvent” you is easy to argue around.
- Tooling agreement
Silicone molds for baby feeding products
Sydney Australia→Shenzhen GuangdongPut mold ownership in a signed agreement, not only on the invoice: list each mold, have it marked with your company name, and give yourself the right to collect it on notice. Factories often refuse to release molds, and an invoice alone is weak proof.
- Manufacturing agreement
LED lighting fixtures
Vancouver Canada→Shenzhen GuangdongState that you own the molds, drawings and specifications you pay for, and that the factory may not make your product for anyone else. If the contract is silent, you will have little to rely on when you want to move production.
- Demand letter
Ceramic tableware
Birmingham United Kingdom→Guangzhou Guangdong- Issue
- Defective or wrong goods
- Amount
- Under USD 50k
- Result
- Settled
Gather the evidence first: the contract or proforma invoice, bank payment records, inspection reports and the WeChat or email history. A letter that cites these documents tells the supplier you are ready to go further.
- Dispute resolution
CNC machine tools
Detroit United States→Dongguan Guangdong- Issue
- Non-delivery after deposit
- Forum
- SCIA arbitration
- Amount
- USD 200–500k
- Result
- Award obtained
First establish whether what you paid was a deposit (定金) or an advance payment, and what delivery date the contract fixed. Under Chinese law, a party that takes a deposit and then fails to perform must return double the deposit (within a statutory cap), which changes the strategy.
Selected cases only. Other 2023 cases are not listed.
2022
- Product development agreement
Wearable fitness trackers
Manchester United Kingdom→Shenzhen GuangdongAgree in writing, before work starts, that you own the design, drawings, firmware and source code. Under Chinese copyright law, commissioned work belongs to the developer unless the contract says otherwise, so silence works against you.
- NNN agreement
Wireless earbuds
San Francisco United States→Shenzhen GuangdongHave the NNN signed by the factory that will actually make your product, not only the trading company you deal with, and make the Chinese text the governing version. If a dispute arises, the Chinese judicial authorities will read the Chinese text and can only hold liable the company that signed.
- Dispute resolution
Automotive parts
Atlanta United States→Guangzhou Guangdong- Issue
- Enforcement of an award
- Forum
- Court proceedings
- Amount
- USD 200–500k
- Result
- Enforced
Before enforcing, find out where the debtor has bank accounts, property or receivables. An award is only worth what can be seized, so asset tracing comes first.
Selected cases only. Other 2022 cases are not listed.
Earlier
Cases before 2022 are not listed here.
Amounts are shown as ranges and dates as years only. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Key points are general lessons from this kind of case, not details of any client’s file.
Sample documents
Dealing with something similar?
Tell me what happened, and I will tell you how it can be handled and whether it is worth pursuing.
Contact Kelly Zhang

